Fisheries Need a Timeout – Unfortunately

The fishing industry is a paradox.

Worldwide, the industry faces a crisis. Dozens of fisheries are no longer commercially viable because we’re harvesting fish faster than they’re being replaced. According to fisheries expert Andrew Rosenberg, our fisheries could provide a 50% better yield than they do right now. That extra yield could mean billions of dollars, thousands of jobs, and countless recreational opportunities.
How could fisheries that are already overfished provide a still greater harvest?

 

A Comparison: Fisheries to a Savings Bank

Rosenberg can explain it; He’s a Regional Director for the National Marine Fisheries Service. Rosenberg likes to compare our fisheries to a savings bank. “Let’s suppose,” he begins, “that you have a bank account with $10,000 in it, and it’s earning 5% interest. If you take 8% each year, then every year the principal is going to go down. Pretty soon, you’re removing 8% of a very small number.”

That, according to Rosenberg, is what we’re doing with commercially desirable fish, except what we’re doing is worse. We’re harvesting an ever larger percentage of an ever smaller number of fish. The result is fisheries that are crashing.

 

Working on Solving the Problem

If instead, to continue the savings bank analogy, we were taking out only 3% from the savings account when it was yielding 5%, we would soon be removing 3% of a larger and larger number. In the case of fishing, if we removed fewer fish than nature replaces, we could, over time, expect the size of the catch to go up as the stocks of fish grew larger.

Rosenberg predicts that if we gave the fisheries a chance, we could see a significant improvement in the number of fish in just three to five years. Eventually, when the fisheries recovered fully, we could be harvesting 50% more fish than we do now. Even better, once the stocks rebounded, we would be able to achieve this harvest on a sustainable basis.

 

Unfortunately, it can harm fishermen

“To get to this point,” says Rosenberg, “we unfortunately will have to reduce the amount of fishing. You don’t want to harm fishermen, but there’s no other way to rebuild stocks.”

Often Rosenberg finds himself in the sad position of attending meetings during which fishermen tell him, “I’m going to lose my house, my boat and everything I have with your restrictions.” But in the end, according to Rosenberg, the problem isn’t the government restrictions, it’s that there are too few fish. The alternatives are either cutting back, or allowing the fisheries to crash, in which case everyone would go out of business anyway.

One ray of hope is a Government buy-out program that would help fishermen by buying their boats and encouraging them to find a different kind of work. It would be like programs the Department of Agriculture had when they paid farmers to idle their fields. The problem with this is the amounts of dollars at stake. “The total investment in fishing vessels far exceeds the investment in all the merchant marine,” points out Rosenberg’s colleague, Michael Sissenwine. “It’s more than half the total value of all other vessels in the world including super tankers and luxury liners.”

 

There are no easy cures to the problem of overfishing.

And the longer we put off dealing with the problem, the more painful the solution will be. However, as both Rosenberg and Sissenwine see it, the sooner we deal with the problem of overfishing, the sooner we can get the economic and recreational benefits of a robust fishing industry.

Search Blogs

Latest Posts

Subscribe to Updates

About Author

Mitzi Perdue is the widow of the poultry magnate, Frank Perdue.  She’s the author of How To Make Your Family Business Last and 52 Tips to Combat Human Trafficking.  Contact her at www.MitziPerdue.com

All Articles

Why You Need a Family Legacy Mindset

Why You Need a Family Legacy Mindset

Why You Need a Family Legacy MindsetWhen Vincent Valeri joined the wealth management industry in 2011, he realized there was an extraordinary gap in what most of these organizations offered and what almost all families need. The organizations, he discovered, might be...

read more
Putting the “Family” in Family Business: It’s Worth It

Putting the “Family” in Family Business: It’s Worth It

Putting the "Family" in Family Business: It's Worth ItHere’s a question for you:  to qualify as a family business, do at least some members of the business need to be related by blood or marriage? Tobi Silver, President of Sterling Resources, LTD has a simple,...

read more
How to Make Your Family Live up to Its Promise

How to Make Your Family Live up to Its Promise

How to Make Your Family Live up to Its PromiseLisa Niemeier, family office consultant and founder of graymatter Strategies LLC, feels that family wealth is a gift. Too often and with too many families, this wonderful gift isn’t allowed to live up to its promise. In...

read more
Silver Arrow’s Secret Sauce: An Investment Thesis Approach

Silver Arrow’s Secret Sauce: An Investment Thesis Approach

Silver Arrow’s Secret Sauce: An Investment Thesis ApproachLet’s suppose a delightful situation.   One way or another (maybe through inheritance, or you got a bonus, or you sold your company) you have some money available to invest. It’s a responsibility. What’s your...

read more
How to Preserve Your Legacy, Using a Stone-Age Technique

How to Preserve Your Legacy, Using a Stone-Age Technique

How to Preserve Your Legacy, Using a Stone-Age TechniqueAndrew Suhl has added an electronic twist to a Stone-Age practice. Amazingly, the ancient practice we’re talking about is one that even today is one of the most essential tools for keeping your family together...

read more
Seven Tips for Personal Cyber Security

Seven Tips for Personal Cyber Security

Seven Tips for Personal Cyber SecurityRajesh Mahadwar, CEO of Softkey,Inc.,  is a great friend of mine, and we bonded over a shared interest in cyber security.  He knows my opinion, that if you don’t get this right, you’re letting yourself in for a world of misery and...

read more