Breast Cancer: Don’t Over diagnose, Do Improve Lifestyle
Avoid Overdiagnosis
When you screen a healthy population for breast cancer, you’re going to get over-diagnosis. This has become particularly evident. As screening practices switched from film-based mammography to digital mammography, we now can detect more small lesions. Only some of those small lesions that we are now detecting will grow into aggressive cancers. For 10-30% of the cases we find a lesion, we don’t necessarily need to cut it out or radiate it; we could follow it to see if it increases in size in a short period of time.
Overdiagnosis is particularly important for older women to consider. We don’t want the elderly woman to feel traumatized by being treated for an indolent lesion; especially when it will not prolong her life and increase her anxiety. Once she’s had lumpectomy and radiation for an indolent lesion, she’ll have follow-up tests for the rest of her life. Overdiagnosis means that she’s likely to endure all this for a condition that might have caused her very little trouble the rest of her life.
To Avoid Overdiagnosis, Only Do Risk-Based Screening
At the Breast Cancer Surveillance Consortium, we’ve developed the free BCSC Risk Calculator. It can be accessed from https://tools.bcsc-scc.org/bc5yearrisk/calculator.htm and downloaded . It’s also available for download to your iPhone from https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/bcsc-risk-calculator/id919034661?mt=8.
One of the goals of the Risk Calculator is to encourage health care providers to assess a woman’s risk before deciding to screen for breast cancer. We now know that it’s common for women to over- or underestimate breast cancer risk. With this tool, health care providers will have a much more accurate picture of a woman’s individual risk; they can then delay screening to a later age and/or screen those who are at low risk for breast cancer less often.
Instead of merely going by age, we can now also take into account other aspects of the patient. We can consider the individual’s ethnicity, breast density, and whether she’s had a first-degree relative with breast cancer. Another thing we could consider is whether she’s had a breast biopsy, and if so, the breast biopsy outcome. The Risk Calculator is free, simple, easy-to-use, and can decrease the risk of overdiagnosis by tailoring screening to a woman’s risk of breast cancer.
We Need a New Paradigm for Responding to Small Lesions
As it is, all small lesions are biopsied to determine if they are cancer. However, some lesions put women at risk for breast cancer, but are not themselves cancer. In the same sense that moderate hypertension is a risk factor for stroke, but hypertension is a condition, not a disease. Whether it’s a small lesion or moderate hypertension, the symptoms bear watching, but they’re symptoms, not the disease itself that requires aggressive treatment. Research is underway to monitor small lesions rather than removing all of them.
Lifestyle Modifications are Important for preventing Breast Cancer
The data are clear: if a woman is overweight or obese and reduces her weight, she’ll reduce her risk of breast cancer.
The data are also clear that exercise is important for risk reduction. She needs to be physically active for at least 20 or 30 minutes for 5 to 7 days per week. A brisk walk is good, taking the stairs, and vigorous housework such as gardening, vacuuming or sweeping will also help. Her goal should be movement as opposed to just sitting.
As for diet, there aren’t enough large-scale diet studies to allow us to say which diet is most protective against breast cancer. A Mediterranean Diet, one that’s high in fruits, vegetables, whole grains, legumes, and nuts, seems to hold some promise, but we aren’t in a position right now to be sure. What we do know is: if your patient is overweight, she needs to consume fewer calories, and whether she’s overweight or not, she needs to exercise 5 to 7 days a week.
Search Articles
Latest Articles
Wisdom from Mitzi Perdue, Daughter of the Sheraton Founder
Wisdom from Mitzi Perdue, Daughter of the Sheraton FounderAbout The Episode In this episode of the Think Millions Podcast, we delve into the extraordinary life of Mitzi Perdue, who has been surrounded by greatness her entire life. As the daughter of Sheraton Hotels...
Frontline Hero: A Combat Medic’s Battle to Save Lives and Limbs
https://foreignpress.org/journalism-resources/frontline-hero-a-combat-medics-battle-to-save-lives-and-limbs Publication –foreignpress.org
Mobilizing Art in Ukraine’s Battle for Freedom
https://foreignpress.org/journalism-resources/mobilizing-art-in-ukraines-battle-for-freedom Publication –foreignpress.org
From Expat Paper to Global Influencer: The Kyiv Post’s Remarkable Journey
https://foreignpress.org/journalism-resources/from-expat-paper-to-global-influencer-the-kyiv-posts-remarkable-journey Publication –foreignpress.org
Subscribe to Updates
About Author
Mitzi Perdue is the widow of the poultry magnate, Frank Perdue. She’s the author of How To Make Your Family Business Last and 52 Tips to Combat Human Trafficking. Contact her at www.MitziPerdue.com
All Articles
A Diabetes Management, Current Therapies
A Diabetes Management, Current Therapies The Bionic Pancreas Offers New Hope For type 1 Diabetes There’s good news for those with type 1 diabetes. The FDA has just approved a device (Medtronic MiniMed 670G) that automates keeping their blood sugar at healthy levels. ...
Transgender Medicine
Transgender MedicineYou Are Likely to Have Transgender Patients All health care providers are going to have a transgender person as a patient at some point. Statistically, roughly one person in 200 has a gender identity that differs from the sex they were assigned at...
Candida Treatment for Simple and Recurrent Cases
Candida Treatment for Simple and Recurrent CasesA Large Number of Women Will Experience a Candida Infection in their Lives In the United States, 75% of women will have a vulvovaginal Candida infection during their lifetimes. In any one year, this means 13 million...
Help For Sexual Dysfunction
Help For Sexual DysfunctionSexual Dysfunction is Common Forty-four percent of women have a sexual complaint. 32% experiencing a lack of desire, 27% not experiencing orgasm, and 21% having pain during sex. Although 44% have a sexual complaint, not all of these women...
Cognitive Problems: Often They’re Treatable
Cognitive Problems: Often They’re Treatable Dementia and Specifically Alzheimer's Disease Dementia are for More Common Than Statistics Indicate The statistic that 5.5 million people in the United States have Alzheimer’s disease dementia is an underestimate. My...
Pelvic Pain: A Different Approach To Treatment
Pelvic Pain: A Different Approach To Treatment Pelvic Pain Is Common And Can Be Debilitating At any one time, as many as 20 percent of reproductive-age women may be experiencing pelvic pain. This can range from a mild ache that comes and goes to steady and severe...